The MOOC ModPo Poem
of the Day for September 29, 2014 is "A Long Dress" by Gertrude
Stein. The poem was first published in Tender Buttons in 1914 and
is in the public domain and therefore legally reprinted here.
Gertrude Stein (1874
- 1946) (pictured) was an American expatriate who lived almost all of her
adult years in Paris. Her abode at 27 rue de Fleurus, where she lived
with her secretary and life-long lesbian lover Alice B. Toklas, was known for
its salons and soirees. Among her frequent guests were Picasso, Matisse,
Juan Gris, Hemingway, Fitzgerald, and Sherwood Anderson, upon whom Stein is
thought by some scholars to have had no small influence.
Said to be analogous
to Cubism, Stein’s poetry, for the most part, eschewed narrative and literal
meaning in favor of a language that used words in a referential rather than
representative manner. Exactly to what her words referred was and is a
matter of some debate, and many critics found and find her work to be
incomprehensible, bizarre ranting, or even gibberish. Her work was
largely self-published and was and is largely unread, despite her fame and
influence.
Fellow writer and
critic Katherine Anne Porter saw Stein’s work as four-dimensional in quality,
showing what is, was, will be, could-have-been, and wasn’t—everything and
nothing all at once. Yes, that is a difficult concept to grasp, and I do
not pretend to grasp it—but I would like to be able to grasp it. To learn
to understand Stein is perhaps to learn to understand language and meaning from
every possible angle, to comprehend a kind of linguistic hypercubism.
Reference to this and additional biographical information may be found
here: http://www.poetryfoundation.org/bio/gertrude-stein.
A Long Dress
Gertrude Stein
What is the current
that makes machinery, that makes it crackle, what is the current that presents
a long line and a necessary waist. What is this current.
What is the wind,
what is it.
Where is the serene
length, it is there and a dark place is not a dark place, only a white and red
are black, only a yellow and green are blue, a pink is scarlet, a bow is every
color. A line distinguishes it. A line just distinguishes it.
Analysis: Stein perhaps used "what"
in a way similar to how Dickinson used "this." Supporting this
is the lack of question marks and the use instead of periods to indicate
statements. So, Stein introduced a new, algebraic meaning for
the word "what," in this case to refer to "the current
that makes machinery." She could have written just as easily,
"X is the current that makes machinery." She went on to define
"what" as "the wind" and as "it."
"Where" is
used in a similarly referential manner. "Where" refers to the abstract concept of length. Abstract, for what is "length,"
particularly if we accept a geometric definition as "an infinite number of
zero-dimensional points strung between two distinct and separate theoretical
points?" For it is between these points that "a dark place is
not a dark place." It is between these points that define geometric
length that there should be the complete darkness of no dimensions, but
surprisingly there is no darkness as the zero-dimensional points coalesce into
the "serene" uni-dimensional concept of line or length--"a
line just distinguishes it."
Returning to
"what," Stein may have meant "what" to refer to the
mysterious force, "current," or phenomenon in the universe that
allows a series of zero-dimensional points to create "a long line"
and a line able to represent a curve or "necessary waist."
Stein supposes a "wind," another kind of force, to be referential of this "what.
Finally, Stein offers an explanation
of what colors are at an atomic level. "A white and a red are
black," in that each piece along something white or red (or any color) can
be theoretically reduced to a colorless or "black" zero-dimensional
point. Pink, which is red (or "scarlet") mixed with white may
be reduced down to scarlet at the atomic level. "Yellow and green
are blue," as any child knows, is a little mixed up, as yellow and blue
make green. However, this "mix up" causes the reader to think
again at the atomic level--yellow and green (chartreuse) reduced to a near zero-dimensional
state will reveal the blue in the green, despite the "extra" yellow.
And a bow? Bows are bent. White light that is bent, as through a
prism, is split into "every color."